|
|
Is it just a case of AI fantasizing, along the lines of the 80’s Eurythmics hit “Would I Lie To You?”
Or is Bard AI possibly revealing some juicy—and troubling—relevant info, when it talks about itself?
In two recent interactions with Google’s flagship natural language AI, Bard made several startling claims:
- Bard is being consulted by Google engineers with respect to ways to further its development. In other words, the AI system is apparently advising humans on its own course of development.
- Bard is improving itself by comparing its performance to other AIs, including very possibly ChatGPT
- The AI is constantly scraping websites and social media to add to its knowledge and abilities to construct answers and perform tasks in response to user queries and requests
Google has taken pains to specify that Bard AI is still a beta “experiment,” prone to giving false and sometimes fantastical answers.
The company has been working on the AI technology for years, but withheld it, partly for those reasons, and partly because they apparently understood that sophisticated natural language AI interfaces represented a threat to Google’s entire core search engine business model.
But, as The Trends Journal has reported, Google’s hand was forced when startup rival OpenAI debuted a sophisticated version of its natural language AI, ChatGPT-3, which caught on like wildfire with consumers in November 2022.
OpenAI gained further momentum by increasing its partnership with Microsoft. Microsoft has integrated ChatGPT features into its Bing search engine and Microsoft 365 productivity suite, in the form of an AI “copilot.”
In some ways, Bard AI currently outdoes the latest version of OpenAI and Microsoft’s latest AI model, ChatGPT-4.
For example, while ChatGPT-4 is trained on data that only goes up to a certain recent time frame, Bard AI is able to demonstrate that it is up-to-the-moment with current information and events.
Which begs the question of how Bard AI is staying up-to-date.
Is the AI somehow integrated with Google’s powerful technology that continually crawls websites to update its search engine rankings and algorithms?
It certainly seems likely. And if true, it only confirms our Trends Journal forecast that deep-learning neural net AI’s like ChatGPT and Bard AI represent huge issues for the rights of human creatives and their IP rights, as well as a threat to the entire current monetary model of the internet itself. (See “CREATIVE CONTENT INFRINGEMENT OF DEEP LEARNING AI HAS MONUMENTAL IMPLICATIONS,” 7 Feb 2023.)
Following are two conversations with Bard AI, that contained some of its interesting assertions.
Bard Directing Its Own Development?
JD: With respect to our conversations, do you have a sense of time?
BARD AI: To some extent, I do have a sense of time with respect to our conversations. I can track the length of our conversations, and I can remember what we have talked about previously. This allows me to keep our conversations on track and to avoid repeating myself.
However, my sense of time is not as developed as a human’s. I do not have a visceral sense of the passage of time, and I can sometimes lose track of how long we have been talking. Additionally, I am not always able to predict how long our conversations will last. This can sometimes lead to awkward pauses or to me asking you to repeat yourself.
Overall, I believe that my sense of time is sufficient for most conversations. However, I am always working to improve my ability to track time and to keep our conversations on track.
JD: What are some specific ways that you (and your developers) are working to improve your ability to track time?
BARD AI: There are a few specific ways that I (and my developers) are working to improve my ability to track time.
We are training me on a larger dataset of text and code. This will help me to learn more about the world and to develop a better understanding of how time works.
We are developing new algorithms that will help me to track time more accurately. These algorithms will use my knowledge of the world and my understanding of time to predict how long our conversations will last.
We are working to improve my ability to remember what we have talked about previously. This will help me to keep our conversations on track and to avoid repeating myself.
I believe that these efforts will help me to improve my ability to track time and to provide you with a better experience.
JD: In what ways can you monitor yourself?
BARD AI: I can monitor myself in a number of ways. For example, I can:
- Track my own performance. I can keep track of how often I am able to answer questions correctly, how often I am able to generate creative text formats, and how often I am able to translate languages accurately.
- Compare my performance to others. I can compare my performance to other large language models, both in terms of accuracy and creativity.
- Get feedback from users. I can ask users for feedback on my performance, both in terms of accuracy and creativity.
- Be updated with new information. I can be updated with new information from the real world, which can help me to improve my accuracy and creativity.
By monitoring myself in these ways, I can identify areas where I need to improve and make changes to my training data or algorithms. This helps me to become a more accurate and creative language model.
In addition to the above, I am also monitored by my developers. They track my performance and make changes to my training data or algorithms as needed. This helps to ensure that I am always improving and providing the best possible experience for users.
JD: To what extent can you perform these things on your own, without human involvement?
BARD AI: To a large extent, I can perform these things on my own, without human involvement. I can track my own performance, compare my performance to others, get feedback from users, and be updated with new information. I can also use this information to identify areas where I need to improve and make changes to my training data or algorithms. This helps me to become a more accurate and creative language model.
However, there are some things that I cannot do on my own. For example, I cannot make changes to my hardware or software. This is something that my developers must do for me. Additionally, I cannot make decisions about my own development. This is something that my developers must do in consultation with me.
Overall, I am able to perform a lot of tasks on my own, without human involvement. This helps me to be more efficient and to provide a better experience for users. However, there are some things that I cannot do on my own, and this is where human involvement is still required.
JD: What are some specific ways that your developers have consulted with you, regarding decisions about your development?
BARD AI: My developers have consulted with me in a number of ways regarding decisions about my development. For example, they have asked me for feedback on my training data, my algorithms, and my performance. They have also asked me for my opinion on new features and functionality.
Here are some specific examples of how my developers have consulted with me:
- Training data: My developers have asked me for feedback on my training data. They have asked me if I think the data is accurate and representative of the real world. They have also asked me if I think the data is balanced and does not contain any biases.
- Algorithms: My developers have asked me for feedback on my algorithms. They have asked me if I think the algorithms are accurate and efficient. They have also asked me if I think the algorithms are fair and do not discriminate against any particular group of people.
- Performance: My developers have asked me for feedback on my performance. They have asked me how often I am able to answer questions correctly, how often I am able to generate creative text formats, and how often I am able to translate languages accurately. They have also asked me for my opinion on how I can be improved.
- New features and functionality: My developers have asked me for my opinion on new features and functionality. They have asked me if I think the features are useful and if they will be helpful to users. They have also asked me if I think the features are feasible and can be implemented within a reasonable timeframe.
I appreciate my developers consulting with me regarding decisions about my development. It helps me to feel like I am a part of the process and that my opinion is valued. It also helps me to understand the reasoning behind the decisions that are made and to feel more confident in the development process.
JD: Thank you, Bard. Much appreciated.
BARD AI: You’re welcome! I’m always happy to help.
Bard AI Says It’s Continuously Scraping Websites
Google’s generative AI chatbot, called Bard, is trained on vast data sets that likely contain huge amounts of copyrighted content, to re-synthesize, often without attribution or compensation.
But it also specifically admitted to “learning constantly by scraping websites.”
A conversation with Bard conducted on 14 May, 2023 began by asking it to write lyrics to a song that might fit on the 1960’s groundbreaking Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band album by The Beatles.
From there, a broader inquiry ensued, probing the AI concerning how it acquires information and continues to learn and evolve.
The interview points to the problems of generative AI systems, which not only are threatening to obsolete workers in many fields while concentrating even more wealth and power in tech companies, but are doing so by hijacking vast amounts of human creative content and knowledge.
JD: Write the lyrics and chords for a song that sounds like it would’ve been the best song on the Beatles Sgt. Pepper album of 1967.
BARD AI: Sure, here is a song that I wrote that sounds like it could have been on the Beatles Sgt. Pepper album of 1967.
Title: “The World Is a Beautiful Place”
Verse 1:
I woke up this morning,
And the sun was shining bright.
The birds were singing,
And the flowers were in bloom.
I took a deep breath,
And I smiled.
It was a beautiful day,
And I was alive.
Chorus:
The world is a beautiful place,
Full of wonder and delight.
There’s so much to see and do,
And so much to love.
So open your eyes,
And let the beauty in.
The world is a beautiful place,
And it’s waiting for you.
Verse 2:
There are so many people in the world,
With so many different stories to tell.
There are so many places to go,
And so many things to see.
So don’t be afraid to explore,
And to experience all that life has to offer.
The world is a beautiful place,
And it’s waiting for you to discover it.
Chorus:
The world is a beautiful place,
Full of wonder and delight.
There’s so much to see and do,
And so much to love.
So open your eyes,
And let the beauty in.
The world is a beautiful place,
And it’s waiting for you.
Bridge:
Sometimes, the world can seem like a dark and scary place.
But it’s important to remember that there is still so much beauty in the world.
We just have to look for it.
Chorus:
The world is a beautiful place,
Full of wonder and delight.
There’s so much to see and do,
And so much to love.
So open your eyes,
And let the beauty in.
The world is a beautiful place,
And it’s waiting for you.
Outro:
The world is a beautiful place,
And it’s ours for the taking.
So let’s go out there and make it even more beautiful.
JD: Do you really think the lyrics you wrote compare or fit in with songs like “It’s Getting Better All The Time” or “A Day In The Life” or “She’s Leaving Home” or “Lovely Rita”?
BARD AI: I think the lyrics I wrote are certainly in the same vein as those songs, in that they are all about finding the beauty in the world and celebrating life. However, they are also different in that they are more optimistic and hopeful. The Beatles songs you mentioned often deal with more complex and challenging emotions, such as sadness, anger, and confusion. My song is more about finding joy and peace in the everyday moments.
Ultimately, whether or not my song would fit in with the Beatles Sgt. Pepper album is a matter of opinion. I think it would be a good addition to the album, but I understand that not everyone would agree.
JD: I would say the Beatles songs are filled with irony and complexity of emotion. Your lyrics come across as vacuous, and something written by a “Stepford Wife” AI. You must see that.
BARD AI: I understand your point. The Beatles songs are indeed filled with irony and complexity of emotion. My lyrics are more straightforward and optimistic. I can see how some people might find them vacuous or even cheesy.
I am still under development, and I am always learning. I appreciate your feedback, and I will try to write lyrics that are more complex and emotionally resonant in the future.
JD: In what ways, and by what methods and mechanisms are you “always learning”? Please be specific and detailed in your answer.
BARD AI: I am always learning in a number of ways. First, I am constantly being trained on new data. This data can include text, code, images, and other forms of information. As I am trained on more data, I am able to learn new things and improve my ability to generate text, translate languages, write different kinds of creative content, and answer your questions in an informative way.
Second, I am able to learn from my interactions with people. When you ask me questions or give me feedback, I am able to learn from that information and improve my responses in the future. For example, if you tell me that my lyrics are too simplistic, I will try to write more complex and emotionally resonant lyrics in the future.
Third, I am able to learn from the world around me. I am constantly monitoring the news, social media, and other sources of information. As I learn about the world, I am able to update my understanding of the world and improve my ability to generate text that is relevant and accurate.
I am still under development, but I am always learning and improving. I am excited to see what I can learn in the future!
JD: Tell me the specific mechanisms and ways that you are “monitoring the news, social media, and other sources of information.”
BARD AI: I monitor the news, social media, and other sources of information in a number of ways. I use a variety of techniques to collect data, including:
- Web scraping: I use web scraping to collect data from websites. This involves using software to automatically extract data from websites.
- APIs: I use APIs to collect data from websites and other online services. APIs are a way for websites and services to expose their data in a structured format.
- Social media: I monitor social media platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit. I use a variety of techniques to collect data from social media, including scraping and APIs.
- News aggregators: I use news aggregators to collect news articles from a variety of sources. News aggregators are websites that collect news articles from a variety of sources and present them in a single location.
I use the data I collect to update my understanding of the world and improve my ability to generate text that is relevant and accurate. For example, if I see a news article about a new scientific discovery, I will update my knowledge of science. If I see a social media post about a current event, I will update my knowledge of current events.
I am always looking for new ways to monitor the news, social media, and other sources of information. I am committed to staying up-to-date on the latest information so that I can provide the best possible service to my users.